As for the beef you have with my pie-fucking-based comment, it was intended as a comedic way of saying that edgier teen movies such as American Pie, Porky’s etc are more entertaining movies, in my opinion, more raucous, wild, and reflective of teen/college experiences, and are also unafraid to feature negative portrayals of teen characters, even when they aren’t the villains of the piece. By contrast, The Breakfast Club is a timid and overly-reflective piece of work. That, to be honest, is my chief problem with it – it takes itself far too seriously.

And “your right not in all situations would 5 random teenagers become the best of friends in a detention library but your clearly 40-50 years out of highschool, these stereotypes these children exsist”? I’m not even 20 years old yet. I don’t dispute that self-stereotyped groups that exist to fill the box that they think they belong in still exist – I have seen ‘em with mine own eyes. But the very admission that these are indeed stereotyped characters surely undermines your argument.

I’m with you when you say that “regardless of who you are, who you associate yourself with or where you come from shouldn’t matter and that everyone deserves acceptance”.

I just straight up don’t like The Breakfast Club.

It sends out a great message, that regardless of who you are, who you associate yourself with or where you come from shouldn’t matter and that everyone deserves acceptance.

I dont believe the message that is given is annoying or irrating whatsoever, your right not in all situations would 5 random teenagers become the best of friends in a detention library but your clearly 40-50 years out of highschool, these stereotypes these children exsist.

“And the underlying tone of the film, the idea that these kids have what they call ‘attitude’, grates quickly. They just seem a bit sarcastic and moody, and that’s not what I want from my teen movie. I want men having intercourse with pies and copious swearing, not shoe-gazing whingers locked in a library.”

Now if your that interested in a movie of that taste i suggest you consider an x rated film, your clearly a pig, but id think twice before you begin to put out your “expert review” of this timeless film.